Top Ten Tuesday is an original weekly meme feature created at The Broke and the Bookish. We’d love to share our lists with other bookish folks and would LOVE to see your top ten lists. For the list of past topics and future schedule, click here.
Hating on My Loves
This week’s topic was a choice: characters everyone loves but I don’t, or characters I love who others dislike. Obviously, I chose the latter.
Alaska – Looking for Alaska
I have been the unlucky one at a table full of master literature teachers who were hardcore hating on Alaska because of one scene in the book. Don’t we all do at least one thing we regret? Or one thing that we are proud of? One thing to help another person out? Should we knock the whole book because of one scene? If so, goodbye Beloved!
If high school students are required to read Toni Morrison’s Beloved, Alaska pales in comparison. Her character – and the focus of the book – are so much bigger than her one teaching moment with Pudge.
Your Amazingness Eludes Me
Just kidding! I chose to do a mix of both sides of the topic!
Holden – Catcher in the Rye
What? Holden is the epitome of a fucked up kid (with absentee parents). He has nothing going for him and is a loser IMO. If we took Holden and dropped him into today’s world, he would be regarded as a jackass.
Pip – Great Expectations
Again, an asshole. A snobbish asshole, according to Cliffnotes. I get it – he comes from a depraved and “common” life. The shits rain down on him. He makes bad choices and shows some redeemable glimmers – but I tried twice to read Great Expectations and had to walk away because of Pip and his dreamworld. If you’re going to dream of the most beautiful world, have some manners up in there!
Edward – Twilight
It has been so long since the books were published and the movies released. The time has come where everything is now scoffed at due to a Twilight trope. However, I still don’t see what the big flipping deal was about Edward. I really don’t.